Case: Dismissed SumoMC vs. Soundi88: SCA 002

[RiceCooker98]

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF ANDORN
SumoMC

Plaintiff,

v.

Soundi88

Defendant.

Case No. SCA 002

Action filed: June, 6th, 2025

Judge Unseatedduke1, CJ

Complaint


JURISDICTION, VENUE, & ADMINISTRATIVE PREREQUISITES
1. This Honorable Court has original jurisdiction over this matter pursuant to Article III of the Constitution of the Republic of Andorn, which states "The Supreme Court can at any time take over the powers of the Federal Court, the Supreme Court can also hear, accept or deny appeals, preside over cases requesting removal of an Elected Official or Appointed Official.",

2. EMERGENCY INJUCTION: The plaintiff hereby request the court grant an emergency injunction to bar SumoMC being removed as President of the Republic of Andorn until this court case is resolved. The Defense is blatant violating the constitution by impeaching and removing a President-Elect which is not prescribed or allowed by the constitution of Andorn.


THE PARTIES
1. SumoMC (“Plaintiff”),
2. Soundi88 (“Defendant”),


FACTUAL BACKGROUND
1. On June 6th, 2025 at 11:37PM EST (4:37PM GMT Screenshot local time) Rep. Soundi88 introduced Articles of Impeachment against President SumoMC in his capacity of President and President-Elect,


FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION
1. The Constitution does not give the congress the power to impeach the President-Elect, as they have not taken nor do they hold the Office of the President,

2. Plaintiff asserts that the constitution explicitly only allows the Congress to impeach the President, Vice President, Cabinet Secretary, or the Attorney General.

3. The Plaintiff does not dispute the fact that the Congress has the power to impeach the sitting President, however they can not impeach the President Elect.


PRAYER FOR RELIEF
THEREFORE, Plaintiff requests the Court declare that the President Elect can not be preemptively impeached and removed from office prior to that individual entering his term as President. In addition, we ask the Court to strike the Articles of Impeachment against the President Elect from law.





Respectfully submitted,
Ryan_88
Attorney for Plaintiff

 

[Unseatedduke1]

​

SUA SPONTE DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE​

​

Upon review of the complaint, the court finds that the plaintiff has named an improper party as the defendant in this action. The complaint challenges the constitutional validity of articles of impeachment introduced and/or acted upon by the House of Representatives of the Republic of Andorn. However, the complaint identifies Rep. Soundi88, a single member of the legislative body, as the sole defendant.

The Constitution of the Republic of Andorn vests the power of impeachment not in any one representative, but in the Congress. Any legal challenge to the validity or constitutionality of an impeachment action must be directed toward the institutional actor, not an individual legislator performing their legislative function.

The complaint is dismissed without prejudice due to failure to name the proper party.

Plaintiff may refile the complaint naming the appropriate institutional party, such as the House of Representatives or the Congress of the Republic of Andorn, if so advised;

This dismissal does not constitute a ruling on the merits of the plaintiff’s constitutional claims.